Saturday, January 24, 2009

Edward vs. Harry

Let's have a discussion in my comment box.

Edward Cullen vs Harry Potter



Get this and other HP countdowns at LeakyNews.com

Who would win in a battle??

I have my thoughts that I will being up in the discussion so keep coming back and checking!

29 comments:

Rebecca said...

NO QUESTION!!!

Edward!!!

In my "Fantasy" world, the story of Twilight is so much more real ;-)

Uh... maybe that was TMI :) haha!

Nutty Hamster Chick said...

Ok I dropped everything and ran over here, but sadly I am a twighlight virgin. So sad. Someday I am going to get around to reading it.

I have however read all the Harry Potter books. I loved them, although I am not sure I was totally satisfied with the last one. But it was good enough.

I hope this sparks a great discussion for you.

Taron Anderton Deeds said...

Daylon says Harry but I say Edward because nobody can take out my man.
ha ha ha

Oh hold on......Daylon says he wins himself because neither one of them are real "so wake up CRACK HEADS"

But we all know Edward would win!

My Diary said...

I am gonna go with Harry. He can block Edwards mind from his then use is magic and turn Edward in a real cold stone. Yeah Harry would win a battle.

As for winning in hotness it is of course Edward, besides Harry is so young it would be a bit pedophilish to think of him as hot.

Mel said...

EDWARD.

Kritta22 said...

What about Harry's ability to block someone from reading his mind???

Would Edward have a chance if he couldn't read his mind??

one day in the life of me said...

Even if Harry could block Edwards mind there is not way Harry could beat Edward. He's much to fast.

So I am going with Edward!

I am LoW said...

Are we talking, "in a fight"? Cause I don't know.

But if you ask who is hottest (which is most important), most DEF- Edward!! hahaha!!!

I am LoW said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
I am LoW said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
chellekay said...

Edward would of course!

Barbaloot said...

Don't hate me, but I've never seen/read HP. And high, in the movie, when Edward is all hot with his sunglasses and 'I don't care' attitude. Yeah-I kind of love him right then.

amelia bedelia said...

Sorry to say, I'm not into either one of those boys. However, if I had to go by looks, I'd have to say the vampire dude. Plus, if I said Harry, you probably wouldn't talk to me anymore!

devri said...

Harry fo sho!!

Sondra said...

Edward wins it for me.

I guess I never think of Harry in the way I think of Edward. Edward warms my heart....

Now that is in books.... So far in film... I like Harry.. Twilight the movie was a huge disappointment for me. I still love the HP movies and watching the actors grow up as they become better actors.

I sure hope New Moon is better with a new director - maybe a little more character development like the books. But the Movie "Edward" --- oooohhh baby! In film looks- Edward is the man (not in real life though - his homeless self)!

rachel griffith said...

ummm i love harry potter...the storyline.

but no one, quote me, NO ONE compares to my edward!!!

nevadanista said...

This would be pre Bella turning Vampire. If Edward and HP fought before she changed, Harry could cast a bleeding spell on Bella, Edward would go into a frenzy and kill Bella, unable to control himself, at which point Edward would be vulnerable and HP could make easy work of killing him. I was hoping thoughout the Twilight series that someone would lose control and kill Bella :)

Rachel said...

Harry Potter --no contest. Edward would swoom at the sight of Hermione and not be able to focus. He's kind of lame like that.

Kritta22 said...

What about if they got to use their friends?

The Crash Test Dummy said...

Hi Kritta! I'm here. I say EDWARD in a HOT contest, but I've never read the book so I don't know about abilities. I'm a Twilight virgin too. Ha ha Pat!

The Crash Test Dummy said...

And Bella could kick Hermione's booty too.

My Diary said...

No way, Bella is a wimp, Hermione is one tough cookie, plus she has magic and she gets straight A's in all her magic courses. All Bella has ever done is fall down and get rescued.

Jenni Jiggety said...

Edward! Harry would ::::swoon::: at the sight of him and be rendered defenseless.

Emily said...

Harry Potter would kick his ***! And I'm not just saying that because I thought Twilight was so boring it made me puke. Sincerely.

Jenny said...

Edward wins my vote. Never have been much of a Harry Potter fan. Guess it could be that my children have worn me out with it all. Infact speaking of potter, my children were watching the 4th movie today.

whoopsadasie said...

I'm going to go with EDWARD hands down!

I have only seen the HP movies..the first 2...couldn't make it past that!

Doty Family said...

I LOVE them both. Harry would have to do some pretty quick spell work. I couldn't watch!! I would want them both to survive, but it would have to be Edward, ultlimately. I feel like I just cheated on Harry!

Nanette Merrill and daughters said...

What a fun battle that would be!

Sissy said...

are you serious? Edward, baby! and I can say this without ever reading a word of Harry Potter or seeing a minute of the movies. yeah, I'm THAT sure of my boyfriend.